If you've broken off one too many corks in the necks of wine bottles, a high-speed, push-button, supposedly-error-free electric corkscrew probably sounds appealing. But after testing a variety of models, we're electing not to go electric (and save up to $30). Here's why:
They're space suckers
You have to devote counter space and an outlet to the charging dock. And if you forget to juice it up before party time, you're right back to corkscrewing by hand. Plus, electric ones are bulky. A manual corkscrew fits in your silverware drawer; one of these guys--as big as 10 inches high and 3 inches wide--needs a permanent home on the countertop docking station or space in a cabinet.
There's plenty of room for operator error
To uncork a bottle, you line up the electric opener over the cork, then press down while you turn on the motor. To pull the cork out, you switch the power button into reverse. But be warned: If you don't have a good grip on the bottle or the right amount of pressure on the opener, your wine bottle could start shaking or, worse, spin out of your hands. And, sorry to say, you may not have seen the end of decapitated corks. Misalign the "worm" (the pointy spiral part) and the cork won't just break, it will become lodged in the device, and to get it out, you'll have to putt apart the protectice plastic shield. Good luck putting that back together again.
The wine world is going screw-top anyway
(Or at least the wine in our world is! Check out all of these great screw-top sippers.)
By Lambeth Hochwald; Photograph by Levi Brown