Chris Reale, 25; Washington, D.C. (11,552 votes)

Profession: Student at The George Washington University Law School; lobbying firm consultant.

Hidden talent: He can throw popcorn 10 feet in the air and catch it in his mouth.

Worst date ever: He took a vegetarian to a steak house, where she just picked at a salad.

Ideal date: Skiing or going to the beach.

Dream girl: A fun, ambitious woman who loves sports.

Why gals should line up: He cooks—Italian, mostly.

… and one last thing: He visits his grandparents in Florida several times a year.

Colleen Hatcher, 26, Indianapolis(4,081 votes)
Profession: ER nurse

Hidden talent: She bakes a mean pineapple upside down cake.

Worst date ever: One blind date turned out to be a registered sex offender.

Ideal date: A Colts game.

Dream guy: Someone honest and family-oriented—she has three siblings, 24 aunts and uncles and 31 first cousins.

Why guys should line up: She likes football! And she’ll nurse you when you’re sick.

… and one last thing: She’s been crashing with her friends, a married couple, since the winter of 2007—save her!