Taste Test: The Best Cookie Dough

We taste-tested dozens of cookie doughs from the grocery store and picked our favorites.
cookie dough

Best Chocolate Chip
Immaculate Baking Company Supremes Chocolate Chunk
After biting into one of these chunky cookies, a tester raved, "No skimping on chocolate here!" She wasn't lying: Semisweet and milk chocolate morsels make up a whopping 25 percent of these bad boys. The remainder is rich, buttery, vanilla-scented dough. "This is what all other chocolate chip cookies aspire to be," one admirer swooned. ($3.99 for 14 ounces, at grocery stores)

parfait

Try it with:

 

Best Oddball
Nestlé Toll House Ultimates Chocolate Chip Cookies with Caramel Filling
What's better than a chocolate chip cookie? A chocolate chip cookie with a gooey caramel filling! Bite into these "thick and tender" rounds when they're fresh out of the oven, and -- surprise! -- they'll ooze creamy caramel. "These cookies are well worth the mess!" one panelist raved. ($3.49 for 16 ounces, at grocery stores)

layer cake

Try it with:

 

Best Sugar
Target Market Pantry Snickerdoodle
Sugar cookies don't have to be boring. Exhibit A: these "melt-in-your-mouth soft" cookies. Cinnamon is the star here -- the dough is laced with a comforting dose, and cinnamon sugar is also sprinkled on top. The result: a pretty treat that one taster imagined would "elevate afternoon tea from humdrum to dreamy." ($2 for 16 ounces, at SuperTarget stores)

Try it with: Hazelnut-Cream-Stuffed Snickerdoodle Sandwich Cookies

 

Best Peanut Butter
Pillsbury Simply Peanut Butter
These smooth, golden-brown treats won over our crowd with their "moist, doughy interior and lightly crisp exterior," as one panelist put it. The peanut butter flavor is strong, but not overpowering: "I can also taste the brown sugar and vanilla," one taster noted. ($3.49 for 14 ounces, at grocery stores)

cookies

Try it with: PB Cookie Sandwiches

 

Best Oatmeal
Wholly Wholesome Oatmeal Raisin
With just 11 (mostly organic) ingredients -- including rolled oats and plump raisins -- these chewy, hearty cookies look and taste homemade. They're a "sweet and salty snack any mom would be happy to serve, and any kid would be thrilled to eat," praised a panelist. ($5.69 for 11.25 ounces, at select grocery stores)

bread

Try it with:

 

Prices and other details were accurate when we published this article in November 2010.

 

Comments