Real-Life Testers: Classic Thanksgiving Dinner Menu Share Print Our mother-daughter real-life tester team, Penny and Bizzy, took our challenge to cook our version of the Classic Thanksgiving Dinner and report back about our turkey, mashed potatoes, Brussels sprouts, stuffing and pumpkin pie feast! Prev Next 4/20 Ready to Roast What's the star of a traditional turkey day meal? Why the turkey, of course! This honking bird takes an hour to prep and an hour and 45 minutes to roast, but the outcome is worth the wait! Get the Roasted Turkey with Thyme Gravy recipe! Get our best 30-minute dinner ideas now!